Stone Circle update, June 2014

by Duncan Lunan - 09:34 on 21 June 2014




Stone Circle update, June 2014


It’s good to see that interest in the future of the stone circle is continuing.   The online petition started by Mandy Collins has now reached and passed its target of 5000.   We had thought that would be the end of it, but the target has now jumped to 8000, so we’ll let it continue!


At the moment the situation is fairly good, but there are a number of issues still to be resolved.   The most important is that we now have a commitment in writing from Glasgow City Council for the first time.   The planning approval for redevelopment which has been issued to the architects specifies that the stones should be removed intact if possible, for re-erection at a site still to be decided.   For their part, the architects are quite confident that because of the way they were put in, it should be possible to reverse the process and extract them one at a time without breaking them, despite the brittleness of the whinstone.


Current thinking is that a part of the existing park will be preserved on the eastern end of the Broomhill top, and there will be a wildlife corridor leading round the hill to it.   Of the possible new sites which the architects suggested to us, that is the best.   It’s where I first went up on to the hilltop in 1978, and even then it had a great surrounding skyline which was obscured only in the northeast quadrant, where the last blocks of flats are now scheduled for demolition.


The redevelopment plan calls for the highest point of the hilltop, where the circle now stands, to be cut off and lowered by up to 12 metres.   The material will be used to flatten most of the existing park to make a plateau, to be occupied by arcs of new housing.   That would obscure the northwestern quadrant of the horizon at the proposed new site, so blocking the midsummer sunset and its flanking lunar alignments for the time being.   We have to think in terms of thousands of years, during which buildings will come and go both nearby and on the skyline, but we also have to think of present-day requirements.   Midsummer sunset has been the most popular event at the circle since it was built, and the most organised support for the campaign to save it has come from the Druid and Pagan communities, of which the City Council is now very much aware.   I have therefore been stressing that if we aren’t going to be able to see midsummer sunset, every effort should be made to preserve a clear sightline to the spring and autumn equinox sunsets, virtually due west by the University spire, with the afterglow showing through it – as in Linda’s photograph in “The Stones and the Stars”, reproduced by Dr. David Clarke in his book “Reflections on the Astronomy of Glasgow”.


Equinox sunset in Glasgow is around 6 pm  (UT), 7 pm BST.   The downside is that at each equinox the Sun’s position changes rapidly on the horizon from day to day, so there’s only one chance to see it, whereas the midsummer sunset alignment can be seen for three days either side of the solstice.   The upside is that there are two chances per year to see it, in spring and autumn.


The questions about the exact placing of the circle remain to be answered, and they will have to wait until the design of the housing on the hilltop has been finalised.   Meanwhile, although the Druid and Pagan groups have officially bid farewell to the site, tokens of respect and affection, for the stones and for the people whose ashes are scattered there, are still being left, and the astronomical story may not be quite over.


While the planning process for redevelopment continues, with less urgency now that the Youth Olympics are no longer a factor, the circle is still in place, and the minor lunar standstill is sneaking up on us.   The four events of northerly and southerly moonrise and moonset at the minor standstill are the only events not yet observed and photographed at the circle.   They are in September and October of 2015, and that seemed a long way away when the threat of demolition first arose in November 2012.   But because the circle has no distant foresights, the diameters of the stones in the foreground will let us capture the events up to a year either side of the standstill itself.   With only one chance per month for each event, with the need to capture them in darkness and when the Moon is significantly past new, and with the Scottish weather, this is just as well.   In 1987, Chris O’Kane and I didn’t manage to capture any of the major standstill events;  in 2006-2007, Mark Runnacles managed to photograph three of them.   (I saw the fourth, when I didn’t have a suitable camera, and Bob Graham managed to get snapshots of it.)   So the planning delays may work to our advantage, and if the circle is still undisturbed in September we can start trying to complete the set of alignment photographs, while making some basic observations relating to the possible new site.


Meanwhile, thanks to the attention which has been drawn to the circle, photographers and artists are continuing to document it at its present location.   In particular, Alastair Mulhearn, Graham Sykes and Jean Pierre St. Martin have allowed us to make use of their work for fundraising and publicity purposes, and it can now be found on our website, www.duncanlunan.com.   Our thanks to them and to everyone who’s supported the campaign thus far.


Duncan and Linda Lunan.










Comment from Helen Wood at 11:58 on 21 June 2014.
Glad there is some positive news. Thanks for standing up for the place. The world needs more people like you.
Comment from Bernie Bell at 10:34 on 23 June 2014.
Keep on, keeping on.
I'm pleased to see you taking a wide view, a 'millenia' view.
These places matter, have always mattered, will always matter. Buildings and human changes, matter too, to us, but, in the long run, the place, is stil there, is still what it is, and will be.
We just acknowledge, what is.
Comment from Elspeth Gibson at 10:29 on 27 June 2014.
Thanks for update, just returned from morning visit to stones, abundant with wild flowers including some beautiful orchids...
Comment from Arlene Fenstermaker at 18:47 on 27 June 2014.
I am so happy for the news! Good work and keep up the photographs and science around these wonderful stones
Comment from Paul Rybski at 20:22 on 29 June 2014.
I am very happy you are attempting to photograph significant astronomical events from within the circle. These are significantly difficult to obtain, given Glasgow's frequently cloudy and rainy weather. But if they are collected on an easily accessible website, they will provide additional motivation for people to support the petition as an astronomical monument. Please publish the URL for that site in a prominent location.
Comment from Vicky Pritchard at 17:34 on 24 September 2014.
I am pleased that attention has been drawn to this wonderful site. Perhaps it could be included in Open Doors information to give it a wider audience. keep me posted!

Add your comment

Your Name

Your Email (only if you are happy to have it on the site)

Your Comment - no HTML or weblinks

Enter this number in the box below and click Send - why?Unfortunately we have to do this to prevent the system being swamped by automated spam

Please note that whenever you submit something which may be publicly shown on a website you should take care not to make any statements which could be considered defamatory to any person or organisation.
sitemap | cookie policy | privacy policy | accessibility statement